|Introduction|| | Religion
Dhurmukhi Year Festivals/Sankalpam Links 2016-2017 Yajur Upaakarma (Aavani Avittam 18.08.2016) dhurmuki Year's Important Festival days 2016-2017 Dhurmukhi year's Tharppana Sankalpam in Phonetic English Dhurmukhi Year's Festival & Tharpana Sankalpam in Sanskrit Tharppana Manthram (Mantram) in Phonetic English Tharpana Manthram (Mantram) in Sanskrit Poonal Changing Mantram - in Sanskrit Abasthamba Yajur Veda Sandhyavandanam-Sanskrit Sama Veda Tri-kala Sandhyavandanam - in Sanskrit Dhurmukhi Year Srivaishnava Festivals Chart 2016-2017 Yajur Upaakarma Sankalmpam (Aavani Avittam) 18.08.2016 Yajur Upaakarma Sankalmpam (Aavani Avittam) In Tamil Gayatri Japam Sankalmpam (Gayathri 19.08.2016) Rig Veda Avani Avittam Sankalmpam 07.08.2016 Rig Veda Avani Avittam Sankalmpam 07.08.2016 in Tamil Rig Veda Upakarma Mantram 07.08.2016 in Devanagari(Sanskrit) Rig Veda upakarma Sankalmpam 07.08.2016 in Phonetic English Sama Veda Upakarma Mantra 04.09.2016 - Tamil Sama Veda Upakarma Mantra 04.09.2016 - Phonetic EnglishReligion-Articles Part I
Relavance of Hinduism in Todays World Haldi (Turmeric) Manjal - Kungumam Temple Visits - Importance & Value Yagnjopaveetham (Poonal) (Sacred Thread) Sri Mahavishnu Temples Daily Prayer of Brahmins (Sandhya Vandanam) Signifance of Ekadasi - Ekaadasi Fasting Contradictions in all Religions Oh God, It's about you - More & More Contradictions - I Oh God, It's about you - More & More Contradictions - II Oh God, It's about you - More & More Contradictions - III Oh God, It's about you - More & More Contradictions - IV Oh God, It's about you - More & More Contradictions -V Women & Gayatri Japam Sri Lakshmi Ashtothram - Ashtothra Satha Namavali Sri Vishnu Ashtothra Satha Namavali (108 Vishnu Names) Sri Vishnu Sahasra Namavali (1008 Vishnu Names) Sri Vishnu Sahasranamam - Slokha Meaning Sri Venkatesa Suprabhatham - Slokha Meaning Dharbham the Holy Grass Prapti Siddhi - Prabthi Siddhi - A discussion Significance & Importance of Divine Number 108 Sri Mahalakshmi Temple, Sripuram, VelloreReligion-Articles Part II
Sri Ramanuja & His World view Gurumantram The Vedas, An Introduction Karma, Prabtham & Prarabtham Committing offenses to the Vaishnavas Footprints of Sri Mahavishnu, Vishnupadam Veda & Theory of Quantum Mechanism Om - Aum, the Pranava Mantra Sri Vishnusahasranamam & Nakshatra (Stars) Prayer, The Value & Benefits Gayatri Japam, Inner meaning & Scientific Values A question for you - All Srivaishnavites Sri Bhagavad-Gita & Schollars View Sarayogi, Bhootayogi & Brantayogi Sex - Is it Good or Bad? Is Materialism A Correct Philosophy? Abode of Sri Mahavishnu - Vaikunta Origin - Domicile of people Wolrd-over Hari Nama Kirtanam Pongal aka MaNandana (Nandhana) SanNandana (Nandhana)nthi Sri Jayanthi, Janmashtami, Krishna JayanthiSanAthana Dharma
Sanadhana Dharma - An Introduction Adhwaitham - Sri Adhi SanNandana (Nandhana) Dwaitham - Sri Madhvacharya VisishtAthwaitham - Sri Ramanuja Sri Ramanuja, Life & History Sri Ramanuja & Sri Vedanta Desika, A Sketch Sri Ramanuja - History & Life SketchSanAthana Dharma - Other Rituals
Abdapoorthi, Ayush Sooktha Homam Upanayanam - Brahmmobadesam Meaning & Requirements Significance of Seemantham - Seemandam Namaskar ! The Benefits of Prostration Srardha Dharma & TharpaNa Niyama - FAQ Sanathana Dharma - Cow, Crow & Dog!Rishis & Gothra Details
Names of Rishis, The Authors of Rg Veda Names of Rishis & Rishikas II in Alphabetic order Gotra Pattika - Gothraa Pravaram Gotra Pattika - Gothraa Pravaram in Tamil Gotra Rishis - Brief Note Part I Gotra Rishis - Brief Note Part II FAQ & Answers on Gotra & Pravaram Rishis, History & Stories Part I Rishis, History & Stories Part II Rishis, History & Stories Part III Rishis, History & Stories Part IV108 Divya Desam
Srivaishnava 108 DivyaDesam Images/Photos -108 DivyaDEsam Mangalasasana Pasuram Numbers & Kshetram/Azhwar-wise 108 DivyaDesa Names in Devanagari 108 Divya DEsa NAmavaLiDivya Prabhandam
A Brief note on 12 Alwars (Azhwars) Divyaprabandam Pasurams 0001 to 0751 Divyaprabandham Pasurams 0752 to 1447 Divyaprabandham Pasurams 1448 to 2081 Divyaprabandham Pasurams 2082 to 3122 Divyaprabandham Pasurams 3123_4000 Desika Prabandham by Sri Nigamantha DesikanPuranas & Ithihas Temple Funds - Appeal Religion-Others
| | Lifestyle
My Family Photo Album Women in Hindu Dharma - A tribute to Women" The meaning of Sri, Sree and Shree Science, Not a Fiction- "Primordial soup!" Deepavali Festival (Diwali) Navaratri - Dasserah, Dasa Raath Purattasi_MaviLakku (Saturday)> Significance of Akshya Tritiya Women, Ornament & Jewellery Jewellery - Mukkuthi - Mookuthi - Nath Sex, It Is Part Of Life- I Go Bananas! - BANANA Tree Usages Churning Of The Sea A Joke For All Tulsi (Thulsi) & Vilvam Sex It Is Part Of Life - II Sex & Yoga - III The Significance of Kolam aka Rangoli Proud India, A reason to smile Divorce? Think twice before you Act Dancing TRS Iyengar, Here & NowTraditional Iyengar Reciepes
Sweet Items Iyengar Special Recipes South Indian Rice Made Items Iyengar specials Vegetable Curry Items Soth Indian Recipe South Indian Iyengar Sambar - Rasam Items List of Items - Glossary - Names in LanguagesWomen's Section
|| Matrimonial|| | Astrology
Astrology - Predictions Astrology, Myth & Facts Navagraha Preethi Star Matchings Value Naming As Per Astrology Namanakshatra, Rasi & Name Chart Star Matching Table Star Matching Table - In Tamil Star Matching - Facts to know Know your Chandrashtamam stars Horoscope Chart - A laymans view Grahana Peeta Sahnti Pariharam How to use a Panchangam - Almanac Astrology, Gemology & Medicine Astrology - Astrologer Vs. Quacks Sukra The Venus & Srirangam Ranganathar Guru The Jupiter & Kanchipuramr The Planet Saturn & Tirumala Tirupati Karma & Astrology for Srivaishnava Karma & Astrology for Srivaishnava_2016-17
|| Health|| | Images
Image Gallery I
DivyaDesam Iimages - Part 1 DivyaDesam Iimages - Part 2 DivyaDesam Iimages - Part 3 Vishnupiran - images Tirupathi Brahmotsavam images Tirupati Utsavar - images Tirupati Temple/Tower - images Srirangam Temple/Tower images - 1 Srirangam Temple/Tower images - 2 Srirangam Temple/Tower images - 3 Srirangam Temple/Tower images - 4 Srirangam Temple/Tower images - 5 Kancheepuram Temple images - 1 Kancheepuram Temple images - 2 Kancheepuram Temple images - 3 Kancheepuram Temple images - 4 Kanchivaram ProcessionImage Gallery II
Nava Tirupati - Temples Pictures & images Tirukkannamangai Temple Photo & images Madhuvan & Dwarka, Photo, Images Pandharpur Sri Vithoba - Vittala, Images, Pictures ThiruvaheendipuramImage Gallery III
Hayagriva - Hayagreevar - images Kumbakonam Sarngapani Temple - images Uppili, Vennar & Madurantakam images Srirangam, Srivilliputtur & Triplicane Ankor Wat Cambodia, Sri Vishnu Temple Akshar Dham, - Akshardham - Delhi - images Ladavaram Nadathur Ammal Temple Sri Mahalakshmi Temple, Sripuram, Vellore
|| FAQ||| Guest Book||| Support Me||| Forum||| Announcements||| Advt. Policy|
|Home » Religion Articles » Who is True God? NarayaNa !||Text Size|
The following are the further arguments put forth by Mr. Elias D'costa. This is in response to Mr. Srinivasan's above post and I reproduce the same without editing or modifying the contents. In all fairness, I reproduce his mail as it isl I got from Mr. D'costa - TRS Iyengar
Thank you for your e-mail, and I am sorry I could not reply earlier, as I was very busy. I like to wish you and your family a very happy new year 2005.
I am very glad that you begin your email by saying "In seeking Truth........." and that is precisely my conviction. It is not what I believe or what you believe or somebody else believes.
According to Correspondence Theory of Truth, any Statement, Thought, or Belief must correspond to reality.
Paul Copan in the Book "True For You, But Not For Me" says "In this book, I am arguing for a correspondence view of truth. That is, proposition or ideas correspond to reality, to the facts, to the real world" (Paul Copan, "True For You, But Not For Me", Bethany house publishers 1998, page 173)
Let us see where the evidence leads us about this one true Universal God.
You claim "Deep Logical approach on any Subject goes endless and finally NOWHERE.... How?". You then give an analogy of beggar asking for alms and addressing the lady as 'Mother', you then conclude by saying "we have to ANALYZE BY BRAIN .... But UNDERSTAND and REALIZE BY HEART."
According to you, this lady is obstinate on her own Inferences and Self-centered, because of the argument of the word 'Mother'.
Srinivasan, you are then implying that the word 'Mother' has no meaning. In logic, if any word means anything and everything - Then it means nothing, it becomes any empty term. Are you able to live by this philosophy?
Let us assume this lady is your mother, and the state issues a 10 million dollar reward to Srinivasan's mother, using your philosophy of "ANALYZE BY BRAIN .... But UNDERSTAND and REALIZE BY HEART" any person who claims as 'Mother' should be awarded the 10 million dollar. You see how ridiculous it gets?
Imagine two ladies A & B, claiming to be your biological mother. Logically, both A & B cannot be your mother, either it is A or it is B or it is possible both lady A and lady B are lying. - The issue here is the Truth, not your feelings of the heart.
You claim: Hinduism is "SANATHANA-DHARMA" and "IS A COMBINATION OR MOSAIC-PATTERN or the COMPOSITE-FORM of several Great Religions."
Response: Based on your philosophy, Hinduism is like a cosmic vacuum cleaner, which sucks in everything viz Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Sikhism, Jainism, Atheism, Skepticism etc.
Just because all religions have terminology like god, eternal, divine, commandments, grace, omnipotent etc...it does not mean that all religions are same and worshipping the same god. It is like saying all of us have same car, just because it has wheels, doors, lights, dashboard, rooftop etc.... You see how ridiculous and absurd it gets?
Srinivasan, You make the following bold assertion about Hinduism:
1) Differences in Hinduism is left to the choice of the man, the God-Seeker....
2) Nobody is compelled to follow a specific part of these Gospels...or Divine-Commandments or the Holy-Stipulations but choose one amongst the Several Options of Various Divine- Paths...
3) Hinduism is the ONLY RELIGION OFFERING ABUNDANT FREEDOM
4) Offering various and divergent Options?
5) Hinduism leads the Man to the Highest Degree of BROAD-MINDEDNESS and LARGE-HEARTEDNESS coupled with UNIVERSAL-LOVE.
6) Man-made Supplements and Insertions in the name of Puranas and Stories so as to suit the Divergent-Interpreter's own personal contentions....
7) Taking advantage of the abundant Freedom this Religion offers
8) These branches of Hinduism have been subsequently created by some individual-Religious-Sectarian-Leaders
You then disagree by saying "Further it is wrong to say that the Hindus are worshipping 330 million forms of Gods. No. Not at all."
You see the problem with Hinduism, is that it has opened it's arms so wide, - it allows people to make own choices of seeking God - there is no compulsion
- you can choose one amongst several options
-offers abundant freedom
- offers various divergent offerings
- it is BROAD-MINDED
- it is LARGE-HEARTED
- there are Man-made supplements and Insertions
- it can suit personal tastes
- and finally the religion is created by some individual-Religious-Sectarian-Leaders,
Well, with the above characteristics and traits, I will not be surprised in another 100 years, the number of gods in Hinduism will increase to 350 million. - Is it surprising based on Hindu philosophy? hmmm....something to think about and ponder.
The above eight points prove that Hinduism or Sanathana-Dharma is open to anything and everything, which includes atheism. Srinivasan, you are living in total contradiction,
#1 you spend a great deal of telling me about gods in Hinduism and eternal divine concept and then you contradict by saying even Atheism is accepted. Srinivasan, How can this be? either God exists or he does not exist? what is it? - Can you please make up your mind?
#2 Again, with great interest you spend 2 pages of proving that Hinduism is open to believing in anything and any god will do, later you contradict by telling me with great zeal and passion that the only supreme God is "UNDOUBTEDLY.... MAHA-VISHNU.... or .... NARAYANA... "
Srinivasan, What is it? is MAHA-VISHNU/NARAYANA a supreme God Head OR All gods are same and equal - Can you please make up your mind, so that we can have a meaningful discussion.
If Maha-Vishnu/Narayana is the supreme God Head, then logically all other gods are lesser in stature and have no place in discussion, further your argument that Hinduism is open to anything and everything falls to the ground.
But, if you hold to the argument that Hinduism is open to the choice of the seekers and any god will do because of the abundant freedom, then logically, Maha-Vishnu/Narayana cannot be the supreme God Head.
Remember, the focus is in the Truth of knowing who this supreme God Head is. Something is not true, just because you believe it. You should believe if there is facts and evidence of truth.
Jan. 06, 2005
Following is the mail I recieved from Mr. D'costa in reply and response to Mr. Parameswaran s post. As usual, I reproduce the same without editing the contents. - TRS Iyengar
Thank you for your e-mail, I am hoping that you are interested in seeking the truth, otherwise we are just wasting our time Something is not true just because you believe it, we should all believe only if it is true
If I tell you that "Snow is Red" would you believe it? - No Why? - There is no evidence which corresponds to reality. All the evidence shows that snow is white.
Supreme God Head in the Heavenly Kingdom. Because, a Kingdom divided will be ruined.
Your analogy of company hierarchy is incorrect. Every company as one CEO, or one Chairman, or one President who controls and governs the corporation.
Similarly, there is only one Prime Minister or President who governs the country, there cannot be two heads of a country, other wise you will have problems, anarchy and the country or corporation will be ruined.
Jesus says it very clearly in the Bible (Matthew 12:25 ".... Every Kingdom divided against itself will be ruined, and every city or household divided against itself will not stand.")
Similarly, in Spiritual matters there must be One true Supreme God over this Universe. This supreme God must show evidence through the scriptures of the following:
- Creation of the Heavens and the Earth (Universe)
The picture of the Shiva Temple with all the idols inside is good, but it does not prove that Shiva is One true Supreme God of the Universe. There are lot of civilizations around the world which has idols of Gods /Goddesses
made by human hands, and dates back to 2000 - 3000 year old.
Jan. 06, 2005
And now this third one is also from Mr. D'costa in response to Shyamala's post. I think, now I should go for a
"Forum" Mode for the members to discuss the subject thread bare! Reproduced below is Mr. D'costa's mail
received on the 7th of Jan- TRS Iyengar
proven who is the One true Universal God?
help" - Is this true?
- in school the teacher discusses with the students, in college the profess or discusses and argues with the students on
every subject, at office the manager discuss and argues or reasons with the employee on the work to be done. At
the husband discusses with his wife and children.
matters - most of the time we do not ponder and realize the situation.
neither does it mean 9.00.- other wise it is a logical contradiction.
car - You see, both cars cannot be mine, this is logical contradiction. You claim "The Truth is not a arrived as a conclusion
of any logical discussion, it is beyond the grasp of human mind." - Is this true?
the right side at the same time - it is logical contradiction - I either drive on the right side, or the eft side of the road, if I
continue to drive on the left side, I will eventually have a head on collision.
neither can I claim 'Avenue B' to be 'Avenue C' - It is logical contradiction. All of the exit Avenues are not the same.
Continental towers - because 300, 400, 500 Continental towers are different they are not the same. - It is logical
Hari, or Shanti
- because all of them are not 'Elias' - It is logical contradiction.
or 'Hari' or 'Shanti' as 'Elias' - it would be a logical contradiction. Logic helps us to determine the truth, If there is a
contradiction, all of them cannot be true at the same time and in the same context. Only one of them is true.
'Paul' or 'Kumar' You are living in a contradictory world view which is nothing but pluralistic and filled with relativism.
Christ who is the embodiment of all truth. Jesus says in (John 14:6 "I am the way and the truth and the life. No
human mind." but later, you contradict, and with a human mind, you come to a conclusion of a true religion and
quote "there is one true religion and that is universal love."
life forms including humans, the meaning of life, the morality and the final destiny. Can you please give some evidence
of this true religion or God that you know of? -
Remember you haven't proven anything. You talk about the great saints who rose to perfection in God - These are
what if this God is a figment of man's imagination? - Something to think about.
Here is another supportive E-mail reproduced as I got from Dr. Ranjit Dodla, who is currently in the UK.
was going through your website. I must accept
whole-heartedly it is a great effort. I hope SRIMAN
NARAYANA continues in offering His nirheduha kripa so
that you can continue this kaimkaryam. Sri
Madhvacharya in his Upanishad Bhashya has said it is
not important for one to developed right knowledge but
also it is extremely important to criticize wrong
to Dr. Koenraad else while ultimate truth might elude
us it is still possible to criticize and avoid what is
untruth. You might be surprised why I am writing all
these things. As I was going through the arguments of
D'costa, I found another classic case of
missionary on the prowl in guise of a sincere seeker
of truth. His first few mails produced an image as
though he is a sincere seeker but his last mail
addressing Shyamala he says he feels the truth is
there in the bible. So the contradiction starts with
D'costa and not the Veda I guess. So if I somehow
prove to him that SRIMAN NARAYANA is the supreme he
would immediately throw the bible and would start
worshipping NARAYANA. Is this the way a sincere seeker
of truth would behave?
lets begin to have some fun now with some of his
arguments. He says kingdom divided cannot survive
according to Jesus. Let's for a brief moment assume
that Hinduism is a divided house. The very fact it has
survived has classically proved how wrong Jesus was.
Aldous Huxley clearly writes Hinduism withstood the
missionary zeal of Christianity and the onslaught of
Islam. Nowhere in the Vedas itís given as Gods are
fighting with each other rather they are fighting only
the darker forces of evil. Only in Hinduism you can
see lord Shiva praising lord Vishnu and vice versa.
But in exodus your god cannot even stand the worship
of other gods as he clearly states I am a jealous god
worship ye not other gods. D'costa has said that truth
is exclusive. How can that be possible? Truth is
all-inclusive. I'll give you a classic example. In the
Bhagavad Gita the Lord says " I exist in all
these beings, all beings exist in Me, but I am
not in them behold my divine magic, 'O Partha."
as usual a man of Dícostaís nature would
raise his voice and say see how contradictory the
verses are. But let's take the analogy of space and
air. Air exists in space but would you say that space
exists in air. Similarly its the case of truth or god.
Itís totally an all inclusive phenomenon. Again the
entire credit of this analogy should go to Sri
Aurobindo who gave this analogy.
dear friend TRS Iyengar, I ask you to beware of such
souls who are hell bent on tarnishing Sanatana Dharma.
Great eminent people like Bertrand Russell and Shaw
have already demolished Bible and Christianity
critically. Paradoxically it was proved to be ONE OF
THE PATHS by Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa.
Unfortunately I am very slow in typing so I will break
rest of his arguments in my future mails.
Jan. 10, 2005
discussion is continued in the next page..________________________________________________________________________________________________
New page article here